Three different questions
Diminishing returns asks what one more unit of ONE input adds while the rest stay fixed. Returns to scale asks what happens to output when EVERY input is multiplied by the same factor. Economies of scale asks whether the average cost of a unit falls as planned output grows.
The first is a short-run idea: in the short run something, such as the building or the machines, cannot change. The second and third are long-run ideas, because in the long run every input can change. OpenStax draws the same line. Diminishing marginal productivity appears when capital is fixed, and the long-run average cost curve only exists once all costs can vary.
Worked example
Idea | Time frame | Measured in
Diminishing returns | Short run, one input varies | Extra output per added unit
Returns to scale | Long run, all inputs scale together | Total output
Economies of scale | Long run | Average cost per unit
Diminishing returns: one input moves, the rest are fixed
Take a workshop whose output depends on machines (K) and workers (L): Q = 10 × K^0.5 × L^0.5. In the short run it has 4 machines and cannot buy more, so output is 20 × √L. Add workers one at a time and total output keeps rising, but each worker adds less than the one before.
That shrinking extra output is diminishing returns, also called diminishing marginal product. It does not mean output falls: total output is still climbing at the sixth worker. It means the same 4 machines are being shared by more people.
Worked example
Workers | Output | Added by that worker
1 | 20.00 | 20.00
2 | 28.28 | 8.28
3 | 34.64 | 6.36
4 | 40.00 | 5.36
5 | 44.72 | 4.72
6 | 48.99 | 4.27
Returns to scale: double everything and compare
Now let the workshop double its machines and its workers together, from 4 machines and 9 workers to 8 and 18. The test is simply whether output more than doubles, exactly doubles, or less than doubles.
For a production function of the form Q = A × K^α × L^β (the Cobb-Douglas form), the answer comes from adding the exponents. Doubling every input multiplies output by 2 raised to the power α + β, so a sum above 1 means increasing returns, exactly 1 means constant returns, and below 1 means decreasing returns.
Worked example
Exponents | Output at 4 machines, 9 workers | At 8 and 18 | Output multiplied by | Returns to scale
0.5 and 0.5 | 60.00 | 120.00 | 2.000 | Constant
0.6 and 0.6 | 85.86 | 197.25 | 2.297 | Increasing
0.4 and 0.4 | 41.93 | 73.00 | 1.741 | Decreasing
Why diminishing returns and increasing returns to scale can both be true
This is what most exam questions on the topic are testing. The workshop with exponents of 0.6 has increasing returns to scale: doubling everything multiplies its output by 2.297. Yet hold its machines at 4 and add workers one at a time, and each extra worker still adds less than the last.
There is no contradiction, because the two tests change different things. Diminishing returns comes from crowding a fixed input; returns to scale asks what happens when nothing is fixed. In a Cobb-Douglas function, the marginal product of an input falls whenever that input's own exponent is below 1, whatever the exponents add up to. OpenStax notes the same thing from the cost side: an industry can show both.
Worked example
Exponent 0.6 on each input, machines fixed at 4
Workers | Output | Added by that worker
1 | 22.97 | 22.97
2 | 34.82 | 11.85
3 | 44.41 | 9.59
4 | 52.78 | 8.37
5 | 60.34 | 7.56
Economies of scale: the same story told in cost
Economies of scale is a statement about long-run average cost: as the firm plans for more output, the cost of each unit falls. If input prices stay fixed, it follows directly from returns to scale. Price machines and workers at $10 each and choose the cheapest mix, and the constant-returns workshop costs $2.00 a unit at every size, the increasing-returns one gets cheaper per unit as it grows, and the decreasing-returns one gets dearer.
The two ideas are still not the same, because cost also depends on what inputs cost. A firm with constant returns to scale enjoys economies of scale if it buys materials at a bulk discount once it is large; a firm with increasing returns can face rising unit costs if growth forces it to pay more for scarce skills. OpenStax puts the main source of diseconomies of scale in management, because very large firms are hard to coordinate.
Worked example
Average cost per unit, inputs at $10 each
Output | Exponents 0.5 and 0.5 | 0.6 and 0.6 | 0.4 and 0.4
100 | $2.00 | $1.36 | $3.56
200 | $2.00 | $1.21 | $4.23
400 | $2.00 | $1.08 | $5.03
Which one a question is asking about
Look at what is held fixed. If the factory, the land or the number of machines is fixed and workers, fertiliser or hours are added, the question is about diminishing returns. If every input is scaled by the same proportion, it is about returns to scale. If it is about cost per unit as a firm or plant gets bigger, it is about economies or diseconomies of scale.
One more neighbour to keep apart: diminishing marginal utility is about a consumer's satisfaction from one more unit, not a producer's output. The arithmetic looks alike, but the subject is the buyer rather than the firm.
Common mistakes
Treating diminishing returns as falling total output.Total output usually keeps rising; it is the extra output from each added unit that falls.Assuming diminishing returns means decreasing returns to scale.They answer different questions. The 0.6 workshop has diminishing returns to labour and increasing returns to scale at the same time.Doubling only labour and calling the result returns to scale.Returns to scale needs every input scaled by the same factor.Treating economies of scale and increasing returns to scale as the same thing.They line up only while input prices stay fixed; bulk discounts or rising wages break the link.Calling rising short-run marginal cost "diseconomies of scale".Rising short-run cost comes from diminishing returns to a fixed input; diseconomies of scale are a long-run idea about average cost.Mixing up diminishing returns with diminishing marginal utility.One is about production, the other about consumption.
When not to rely only on the calculator
Sources
- Production in the Short Run (section 7.2), OpenStax, Principles of Economics 3e
- Production in the Long Run (section 7.4), OpenStax, Principles of Economics 3e
- Costs in the Long Run (section 7.5), OpenStax, Principles of Economics 3e